10 Venture Red Flags That Mean You Should Probably Walk
I love the optimism of early-stage investing. New ideas, fresh energy, big markets. But optimism without guardrails is how you end up explaining to your investors why a “can’t-miss” deal missed so completely.
This isn’t about being cynical. It’s about being clear-eyed. Most great companies had plenty of hair on the deal. The question isn’t “are there red flags?” — there always are. The question is: When things go wrong — and they will — will this founder figure it out?
Hold that thought.
Start Investing With the AV Syndicate Today
< 3 minutes
How to Use This Advice
Think of red flags as diagnostics, not verdicts. One flag means slow down and dig deeper. Three or four stacking up? That’s usually your cue to walk.
Each section below includes a quick field test you can run in minutes, not weeks. That’s the game: speed with judgment. Your job is to separate “keep going” from “probably not” fast enough to matter.
At Alumni Ventures, we run a diversified portfolio model with heavy co-invest discipline. We see a lot of deals — thousands per year across our network. This post distills patterns we’ve watched play out, both good and bad, across hundreds of companies. If you’re venture curious or thinking about joining one of our funds or syndications, this is our operating system.
Top 10 Red Flags
1. Integrity Gaps
Truth is non-negotiable. If numbers don’t reconcile or stories shift under basic scrutiny, stop. I don’t care how hot the market is.
Quick test: Trace one KPI from a board slide to the source data. Then run two back-channel references — not from their list.
Story: We looked at a fintech lending company in 2019. They pitched 43% month-over-month growth in originations. When we asked for the raw data, the real number was 18% after stripping out internal demos and test accounts. A reference told us they’d been flat-to-negative for two quarters after a key partner fell through. Never disclosed.
We passed. Not because of the bad quarter — good companies have bad quarters. We passed because they hid it.
Walk indicator: Any defensiveness when you ask to trace a KPI to its source.
2. Top-Down Market Math
“$1 Trillion Total Addressable Market times 1%” is noise. It tells me you haven’t chosen a winnable beachhead.
Quick test: Build market calculations bottoms-up. How many likely accounts exist? What will they pay? What’s a conservative conversion rate? Now name the first beachhead you’ll own — and give me 10 referenceable customers who look alike.
Story: A collaboration-tool startup opened with “$2.8 trillion market, we’ll capture 2%.” When we pushed on the beachhead, they went generic: “Everyone from freelancers to Fortune 500.” Their customer logos spanned 31 industries with no pattern.
Two years and $12M later, they’d pivoted three times and sold for parts. Great founders don’t boil the ocean. They boil one pot very, very well — then expand.
Walk indicator: Can’t name the niche they’ll own first.
3. Team Dysfunction
“Zero daylight between founders” doesn’t mean no debate. It means they debate hard, decide, and commit. If they can’t align internally, nobody else will follow them.
Quick test: Ask each founder separately:
- Who owns which decisions?
- What was your last big disagreement and how did you resolve it?
- What are your current roles and vesting terms?
Compare the answers.
Story: In a Series B, two technical co-founders gave us different stories about their biggest disagreement. One said, “We don’t really disagree.” The other described a three-month argument over SMB versus enterprise. Cap table was 50/50, no vesting left, different board voting rights.
That’s not a partnership. That’s a coin flip waiting to happen.
Walk indicator: “We never disagree” or “We always agree.”
4. Lack of Customer Interaction
Ideas break the first time they hit a real customer. If the team isn’t meeting users now, they’ll get humbled later in a more expensive way.
Quick test: Ask for notes from the last 10 customer conversations. What were the reasons for wins and losses? What specific product changes came from those conversations? Then talk to three customers yourself.
Story: A seed-stage healthcare IT startup sent us a beautifully formatted PDF of “customer insights” — no raw notes, no names, no dates. The one “customer” they offered for a reference call was the founder’s sister-in-law, a nurse who’d never used the product.
Walk indicator: Insights without receipts.
5. Funky Cap Table & Terms
Messy structure kills future rounds more reliably than short-term metrics ever will. Watch for these things that that can poison the incentives for everyone downstream:
- Over-dilution: Founders’ ownership falling too low to stay motivated
- Toxic preferences: Investor terms that guarantee outsized returns even in mediocre outcomes
- Ratchets: Clauses that give early investors more equity if later rounds are priced lower, and
- Side letters: Private agreements granting special terms outside the main deal documents, outside of industry norms.
Quick test: Get a one-page cap table (current and pro forma post-round). What’s founder ownership after the next round? What vetoes or side letters exist?
Story: We reviewed a robotics Series B with seven share classes. Founders had 21% combined after two rounds. A side letter gave the Series A lead a 2× liquidation preference and full-ratchet anti-dilution. On paper, there was no oxygen left for future investors — or to motivate the founders.
There’s a difference between strong investor protections and poison pills.
Walk indicator: Anything they “can’t share” about the cap table.
Start Investing With the AV Syndicate Today
< 3 minutes
6. Single Point of Failure (Platform or Regulator)
If the company depends on one platform or regulator without leverage, the downside isn’t “slower growth.” It’s existential.
Quick test: Ask, “What if they say no?” — Apple, OpenAI, FDA, a major payer. What’s Plan B for distribution or margin?
Story: During the Clubhouse boom, a startup built premium features on top of their API. When we asked, “What if Clubhouse shuts off access or builds this themselves?” they waved it off.
We’ve seen this movie with Twitter and Facebook. If the platform can change the rules overnight, it eventually will — always at the worst possible time.
Walk indicator: Hand-waving about platform risk or “we’ll cross that bridge when we get there.”
7. Slow Rate of Learning
Tempo matters. Experiment cadence plus measurement is the heartbeat of building. If the team’s not learning fast, a competitor will.
Quick test: Ask for the experiment log from last quarter. What got tried? What changed? What got killed?
Story: A Series A edtech team sent us a roadmap of shipped features instead of experiments. No kill list. No failed tests. They’d been running the same three channels for 18 months because they were “doing fine.”
Their leading competitor was running 15-20 tests per month and iterating frequently. Guess who won.
Walk indicator: Features shipped as a proxy for learning.
8. There’s a Herd and This Startup Is Nothing New
Hot spaces attract me-too startups. Winners tend to have time-in-market and nonobvious insights. If the pitch is, “It’s hot and we’re smart,” keep your wallet closed.
Quick test: How long has the founder been in the trenches of this domain? What’s the hard-to-copy moat beyond “we’ll execute better”?
Story: During the NFT infra wave, we saw a founder who’d been “in the space” for nine months after leaving Google. The only insight: “Brands want simpler tools.” There were plenty of companies in our pipeline building the same thing.
Great founders can ride waves. The best make them.
Walk indicator: Novelty without depth.
9. Hand-Wavy Numbers
Stage matters — no one expects perfect instrumentation at idea stage. But numerical orientation should show up early. Founders who embrace the math signal discipline.
Quick test: Ask for the right KPIs by channel. What’s Customer Acquisition Cost payback by acquisition source? How’s pipeline health versus plan?
Story: A SaaS company gave us overall retention instead of cohort-by-month. We pushed for discovered paid-acquired customers retained at 45% versus 92% for organic. Their whole CAC payback model relied on blended retention — and they were planning to scale the paid channel.
They weren’t just growing slower than they thought. They were burning money on every marginal customer.
Walk indicator: Averages when you need distributions.
10. Lacks a Vision or Passion
Great founders recruit with a vivid “why.” If the story is all features and no mission, headcount will scale while energy decays.
Quick test: “In five years, what will you have changed for your customer — and why does it matter?”
Story: A tab-management extension had ex-Googlers and a crisp product. We asked, “Why this? Why you?” and got a feature list.
Contrast that with a remote-work tools founder who’d lived the problem for three years and radiated mission: “Make distance irrelevant for teams.” The second founder could hire missionaries, not mercenaries.
Walk indicator: “#1 provider in X” with no human reason underneath.
Start Investing With the AV Syndicate Today
< 3 minutes
What Matters Most
Three drivers dominate outcomes:
- Home
Integrity
Non-negotiable truthfulness - Home
Competitive advantage
Earned insight and/or moat - Home
Learning tempo
A heartbeat of experiments and decisions
Most passes happen for process reasons, not bad luck. You’d be shocked how many deals fall apart on reference checks, missing data, or simple misalignment between founders.
Interactive Case: Two Deals, One Decision
You’ve got $15M to deploy this quarter. Two Series B opportunities need an answer. You can do one — or neither.
Company A: AI Infrastructure Platform
Early 2023, AI explodes. This team helps enterprises deploy LLMs in private clouds. Founder spent five years at AWS. $3.2M Annual Recurring Revenue. Clean data room. Hot deal, two other funds circling.
Pros: Perfect timing. Good logos. Strong polish.
Cons: Fuzzy target market — claims a $50B space but no convincing beachhead. Customers spread across 12 industries with no pattern. Heavy OpenAI dependency with a weak Plan B. Vision felt like “be #1 provider,” not “here’s the pain I must fix.” Also, co-founder just departed for “differences.”
Red flags: Top-down market math, single point of failure, vision gap, possible team dysfunction.
Company B: Pet Wellness Subscription
Late 2019, premium dog food and supplements via subscription. Founder has 11 years in pet nutrition and started formulating in her kitchen three years ago. Real revenue, passionate customers.
Pros: Deep domain expertise. 400+ direct customer conversations with notes. Product iterated four times based on feedback. Strong co-founder trust (worked together 12 years ago). Early product-market fit signals with $1.8M revenue and healthy retention.
Cons: Messy cap table — seed at $12M post with 2× preference, bridge at 25% discount. Only six months of cohort data. Channel concentration (60% Instagram ads). And she had a prior failed startup.
Red flags: Cap table hair, thin data, concentration risk, founder prior failure.
Which would you do?
Plenty of rational investors picked Company A: “Cleaner metrics, hot market, competitive deal.”
Both had red flags. The difference? Why did we go with B? The founder.
Company A’s CEO was running an opportunity. When things got hard, we thought he lacked the grit.
Company B’s founder was running a mission. When things got hard, she adapted — talked to more customers, reallocated spend, diversified channels, cleaned the cap table. Her prior failure didn’t disqualify her. It prepared her.
The critical question: If things go wrong, does this founder have the customer obsession and learning velocity to navigate through? If yes, some process issues are fixable. If no, even clean metrics won’t save you.
Start Investing With the AV Syndicate Today
< 3 minutes
When to Break Your Own Rules
Never break on integrity or team dysfunction. These are foundational. If you compromise here, you’re not investing — you’re gambling.
Maybe bend on process issues — cap table hair, thin data — when founder quality is unmistakable. But be honest: Are you betting on a person you know can learn, or falling in love with a narrative?
Field Checklist: Ten Minutes That Matter
- Home
1. Integrity:
Follow one KPI from slide to source; run two back-channel references. - Home
2. Market:
Build bottoms-up TAM and name the first beachhead with 10 lookalikes. - Home
3. Team:
Ask each founder about decision ownership and their last big dispute. - Home
4. Customers:
Read the last 10 customer notes; call three yourself. - Home
5. Cap Table:
Get a one-pager (now/pro forma); identify preferences and vetoes. - Home
6. Platform/Regulator:
Demand a credible Plan B. - Home
7. Learning:
Review the experiment log and kill list. - Home
8. Herd vs. Moat:
Probe for non-obvious insights and earned advantages. - Home
9. Numbers:
Cut cohorts by channel; compute CAC payback with realistic retention. - Home
10. Vision:
Ask the five-year change question — and why it matters.
If you ran just these ten things consistently, you’d dramatically improve your hit rate and reduce time wasted on the wrong deals.
What This Means for Founders
Treat this as a self-audit: Can you hand your data room to a skeptic and have them trace key KPIs? Do you have a beachhead and a customer pattern you can name in one sentence? Is your cap table clean enough to attract the next round? Are you running experiments or just shipping features?
And the hardest one: If I muted your pitch and just watched you operate for a week, would I see someone running a mission or chasing an opportunity?
What This Means for Investors
Be willing to walk. The venture market doesn’t run out of deals. There’s almost always a second or third chance on great companies.
Share the weaknesses. When you do invest, write down the red flags you’re accepting and why. Tell the founder. Clarity beats conflict later.
Keep the bar on integrity and team. These aren’t “nice to have.” They’re table stakes for trust and execution.
The Takeaway
Venture isn’t about predicting the future. It’s about stacking the odds toward founders who learn faster than their problems grow. Red flags help you see the odds clearly.
Don’t use them to kill curiosity. Use them to focus it.
If you remember just three things:
- Integrity, advantage, learning tempo — if you can only check three boxes, check these
- Platform dependency and cap-table poison are silent killers
- Bet on missions, not moments — the founder compelled to solve a pain will outlast the founder attracted to a trend
Want to go deeper? At AV, we run diversified funds for broad exposure and syndications for single-name investments. Both models use this same framework—fast diligence with discipline. If you want to talk through the checklist or explore ways to participate, reach out.
Red flags aren’t the point. Clarity is. The best founders will welcome your skepticism because it makes them sharper. The best investors will welcome their candor because it makes you partners, not just counterparties.
See you in the next deal.
Join Us (For Free)
Start Investing With the AV Syndicate Today.
- Home
Easy Sign-Up
Enroll in < 3 minutes. - Home
High-Quality Deals
Typically unavailable to individual investors. - Home
Co-Invest With Elite VCs
AV co-investors include VCs like Andreessen Horowitz, Sequoia, Khosla, Accel, and more. - Home
Exclusive Deal Information
Diligence materials, investor decks, company financials all provided. NDA required & enforced.
This communication is neither an offer to sell, nor a solicitation of an offer to purchase, any security. Such offers are made only to eligible investors pursuant to formal offering documents, which describe the risks (which are significant), terms, and important information that must be considered before any investment is made. This communication is not personalized advice to any recipient. This communication includes forward-looking statements, generally consisting of any statement pertaining to any issue other than historical fact, including without limitation predictions, financial projections, the anticipated results of the execution of any plan or strategy, the expectation or belief of the speaker, or other events or circumstances to exist in the future. Forward looking statements are not representations of actual fact, depend on certain assumptions that may not be realized, and are not guaranteed to occur. Any forward-looking statements included in this communication speak only as of the date of the communication. AV and its affiliates disclaim any obligation to update, amend, or alter such forward-looking statements whether due to subsequent events, new information, or otherwise.